by JoeB » Fri Apr 09, 2004 6:49 am
My opinion on any chip is you have to look at it with an open mind. What is it they are supposed to do, and how is this particular one accomplishing it? I ABSOLUTELY believe that they could make a chip to improve performance. What the chip "should" do if done right is modify ECU controled parameters to make your engine run better. That quote earlier is right on, if you supercharge your car or otherwise significantly change the air flow or fuel flow, you need to tune your engine accordingly. These days, all those controls are locked in and controled by the ECU. That is why we use piggyback computers.
The difference is, the chip done right is done SPECIFICALLY for your car with the mods you have done to it at that time. Even if you got that chip specially for your car, what if you make more changes (as most of us do)? Then you can't change the chip or if you do, it's spending a lot of money to get it reflashed. Plus paying a very good tuner for his time to get the required parameters. Yes, I think A chip could help but only if it was done per the above and no changes were made. With a computer like the Split Second FTC1 or the Greddy E-Manage you can manipulate these parameters as changes are made. The Apexi S-AFC-II is fine but only controls fuel.
Gadget is right on, if our ECU's chip is a PROM, it is written to 1 time only. EPROMs can be erased and writen to optically again. EEPROMs can be erased and written to electrically again. The best is the Flash ROM which is simply reprogrammed. Given what we've heard about Toyota's reluctance to share the programming information along with Gadget's knowledge, I'm inclined to believe it cannot be reprogrammed.
So, if you choose to go with a chip, I would recommend you look into how they accomplish it, piggyback (waste of $20) or ECU replacement. If replacement, you need to find out what mods did they tune it for. Then you have to be satisfied that you will not be able to fine tune or re-tune it without a chip change or going ahead and buying the EMS you could have bought with that money in the first place. -JoeB